She looks like an authentic Kailey doll to me! ^_^ She has the sun-streaked blonde hair signature to Kailey, which none of the AGT dolls have. Also, her hair is too dark to be AGT #22 and she lacks #24's freckles. I'd say she's the real deal, I don't know why the buyer thinks otherwise. [img]graemlins/wonder.gif[/img] Hope that helps!